Bakersville Elementary, 1999
***
“Can I have lunch here, Miss Phoebe?” Emily said. Miss Phoebe looked sadly over at her and nodded.
She had gone to the teacher’s lounge during the lunch break, when everyone else was having lunch in the cafeteria. She had been going for the past week, because she couldn’t eat at the cafeteria anymore. And it was all because of Gabriel.
She settled into a seat next to the window and opened her lunchbox. Her mother had packed the green grapes again. She didn’t like them. She always gave them to Gabriel who gave her the red ones instead, the ones he didn’t like but she loved.
She wondered if they would ever be friends again.
It had all started when Gabriel decided to become one of the popular kids. Emily had supported him even when she knew that it was a bad idea. She knew it would end badly. She just didn’t know that it would end badly for her. The first and most obvious step for Gabriel to become popular was to stop hanging out with Emily. She was the one who suggested it.
It hurt her a bit when Gabriel agreed with it immediately. He went to Miss Phoebe and asked to switch seats. It worked like a charm because the other kids asked to play with him during recess. The next step was to stop reading during Reading Time, and he started shooting spitballs at Emily, who was now the only person in the whole class who read during Reading Time.
Gabriel became popular in a week. Emily was right. It came so easily for him. She was happy for him. She had to be, given that she was the one who encouraged him to do it. It wasn’t all that bad, though, because they hang out at home. she looked forward to evenings. They didn’t walk home together anymore, and she had to wait to hear him downstairs.
She couldn’t go to his house because he’d joined various clubs so she wasn’t sure if she could find him. More than that, she wasn’t sure when his friends were coming over and she didn’t want to spoil anything for him. They would hang out just like old times. They would read comics, do their homework together and play board games. She liked that he had decided to be popular but still stay on top of his school work.
The time felt short but she treasured it regardless.
It had been two weeks since Gabriel became popular. It was a school day but she couldn’t go because she was running a fever. Terry had already called the school and had given her some medicine and put her to bed. She slept through the day until she was woken up by a soft knock at her door.
“It’s me,” Gabriel whispered as he walked into her room, “your mum said I could come in for a little while but I’m not supposed to make you play.” Emily sat up in her bed and smiled at him. He laughed and she looked at him quizzically.
“I didn’t know I had retainers,” he said, pointing to her mouth.
She was immediately embarrassed. She hadn’t realized she had her retainers in, but of course she did, given that she had slept in the whole day. She removed them quickly. They spent the rest of the evening reading and he caught her up on what had happened in school that day, and as she walked him to the door, she couldn’t help but feel uneasy. She just didn’t know why.
Her unease made sense when a day later she got to school and realized that the other kids whispered in each other’s ears when she walked past. She wasn’t sure what was going on but she didn’t need to wait too long to find out. She was sitting alone at a table during the lunch break, having her lunch when she felt a crowd of kids surround her.
“We heard you sleep in retainers,” one of the kids said and the rest of them laughed.
Emily was shattered. She looked through the crowd to see if she could spot Gabriel but he was nowhere to be found.
She sat through a full half hour of being taunted and teased, being called an Ugly Duckling and other mean things that only mean kids could say. By the time the lunch break was over she had cried herself into a fit of hiccups. She went to the nurse’s office and asked if she could be allowed to go home early. Her mother was called and came to school immediately. On the ride home, she cried even more. She cried to her heart’s content.
“Is everything okay?” Terry asked when she had driven into their garage and given her some time to calm down.
“Gabriel told the other kids in school that I use a retainer. They’ve made fun of me the whole day,” Emily said as she broke down into another fit of tears. Terry sighed deeply. She didn’t know what to say to her daughter.
“Should I tell Gabriel he can’t come over anymore?” she asked, hoping that it was at least something.
“I don’t think he will. Our friendship is over now,” Emily said as she jumped out of the car and ran into the house. She refused to come out for dinner even when her Dad tried to coax her with her favorite brownies.
She spent the whole night crying, but when the next day came, she was out of tears.
She decided that she wasn’t going to cry over Gabriel and the rest anymore. She decided that she had been doing well before him, and she would do even better now that they were no longer friends.
She went to school and held her head high as she walked to her seat, and she ignored all the whispers. She knew she couldn’t eat at the cafeteria for a while so she asked Miss Phoebe if she could eat at the teacher’s lounge for a few days. Things would go back to normal, she knew.
And when they did, she would never think about Gabriel again. He was dead to her.
EMILY***“His name is Harry,” I said into the phone, ignoring the fact that Nila looked up from her books when I did.It was not yet time for our weekly phone call but I just had to call Julie and update her on what was going on in my life. It was exciting, after all. I had only ever had one other boyfriend and after things ended the way they did, Julie kept encouraging me to try and like someone else, or, at the very least, to try and not sabotage things when I actually did, but I always did.I was afraid. But there was something about Harry that made me feel brave. Maybe it was the fact that this was a new environment. Maybe it was the fact that even with Gabriel here, I felt like I could start afresh in some areas because at least here my reputation was not tarnished like the way it was back in Bakersville.Knowing people your whole life did have some disadvantages. I smiled as Julie squealed into the phone. I was just as excited as she was. I told him about our interaction in cla
GABRIEL***“You did what?” I shouted over the phone. I would regret it later but I was too shocked to remember that my Mom didn’t like it when people raised their voices at her.“I called Terry. Planned a dinner date with the both of you,” Mom said, and I had to physically stop myself from screaming into the phone.I had hoped that moving to Cresswell wouldn’t mean my Mom and Emily’s Mom getting together, but then, it was just a matter of time before it happened. I guess what I should have hoped for instead was for it to take much longer than it did.“Have you told Emily yet?” I asked, putting on my jacket. I wanted to look for her. Tell her myself. Ask her to come up with an excuse, even. Or come up with one myself, so that we could push the dinner as far as we could.“I got her number from Terry and I texted her, telling her that we’d moved here and that you’re in the same school,” Mom said.“Really? Has she responded?”“Yes. She said you haven’t met yet but she’ll look for you n
EMILY***“Emily, come get the door,” Mom said.I wanted to ignore her but I knew she knew I had heard her. It was only the two of us in the house, after all. I didn’t want to get the door. I didn’t want this day to come. I had been dreading it but that didn’t change things. It was here. Oh well, might as well get it over with.I got up from my bed and made my way downstairs. The only reason I didn’t drag my feet was that Louise was outside. The other party, I didn’t care much for. I took a deep breath then I opened the door.“Hi,” Gabriel said as he made his way past me, making sure to hit my shoulder as he did.He was so full of it. I wanted to roll my eyes but I didn’t. I put on the warmest smile I could muster for Louise.“It’s so good to see you,” she said as she gave me a hug.“It’s good to see you too,” I said and I meant it.I had missed her. She was like my second mother and my friend. I had always been sorry about the way I left things with her. I should have told her I was
(Bakersville Elementary 2001)***“You will be doing your elementary school Science Fair Project in pairs,” Mrs. Berry said. There were mixed reactions in the class. Some people were excited. Others, not so much.Emily was excited. It didn’t matter who she got as a partner, she was excited about doing the science fair project. She already had an idea in mind.“Do we get to choose our partners?” a student asked, and everyone quieted down. This was the most important part. A ‘yes’ from Mrs. Berry meant the world to the elementary school class. it would mean they could choose their crushes. It meant their dreams could come true. Mrs. Berry had the rare and unique chance of being Cupid. Would she take it?The air was thick with anticipation. Everyone was holding their breath. Well, almost everyone. Emily didn’t care much for crushes. She didn’t have one, and she was sure no one had a crush on her as well.“No,” Mrs. Berry said and the class deflated with disappointment.Mrs. Berry smiled
GABRIEL***“I’m so happy for you,” Mom said as she reached her hand across the table to hold Emily’s.Emily had just announced that she was dating Harry. And I hoped she was lying. Besides, it didn’t make sense. The only reason Harry could have been holding Emily’s phone on the day we met was that he was giving her his number, and he’d also told her to call him. If they were dating, they wouldn’t need to tell each other that. Moreso, he wouldn’t need to tell her to call him. He would call her, right? Isn’t that what boyfriends did?I’d only come to this conclusion because I had been thinking about it for the four days that had gone by since it happened. It bothered me that they might have been dating this whole time. But that’s not what bothered me the most. What bothered me was how she acted when I grabbed her wrist. She said she was okay but I doubted it. I was worried for her. What had happened to make her so scared?I had debated texting her, to ask her if she was okay. I knew sh
EMILY***This is not what I had planned. I shouldn’t have allowed my desire for revenge to take over. I regretted it as soon as I said it, not only because I was dragging Harry into my drama with Gabriel, but also because Gabriel seemed unaffected by the news. I had a feeling he knew I was lying. It pissed me off all the more that he knew but he chose to play along.What pissed me off even more, though, was the fact that when he was asked if he was dating he said no. He didn’t play along. He didn’t try to pretend the way I was. It was like he was uninterested, unbothered. But the Gabriel I knew was not the type to be upstaged. I had hit him where it hurt. It’s not that he wasn’t affected. It’s that he was coming up with a strategy.I could tell by the way he got silent for the rest of the dinner. I could almost hear his brain turning. As soon as we waved them goodbye I ran up to my room. I needed to text Harry. I paced around my room. What was I even going to say? How would I bring i
EMILY*** “Thanks again for agreeing to meet me,” I said to Harry as I sat down. We’d decided to meet at a coffee shop off campus. It was my suggestion. I didn’t know where Gabriel was and I didn’t want to run the risk of running into him before I told Harry what I had done. “Sure,” Harry said, “is everything okay? You look pale.” I was anxious. I had never done anything like this, and I hated that I was doing it to someone who didn’t deserve it. Someone who was genuinely interested in me, that I was genuinely interested in as well. I hated that I was dragging him into this. “I’m okay,” I said, “probably just tired from the weekend. It was a lot.” “How was the dinner?” he asked. I guess we were getting straight to the point. “It was great. I hadn’t seen Gabriel and his Mom in a while so it was great to catch up on things,” I said, sipping on my Iced Americano. “That’s great to hear. What did you want to tell me?” he asked. I placed my drink on the table and took a deep breath
GABRIEL***“Glad you could make it,” I said to Harry as he sat down across from me. He’d asked to meet at a coffee shop off campus. He didn’t seem happy to be here. Emily must have told him about what happened between us. I didn’t blame him, though, that he’d chosen to take Emily’s side over mine. It made sense. I would just have to plead my case. “Make it quick,” he said.He was acting hostile, probably because of what Emily told him about me but I needed to make sure that he felt that I was genuine. It was going to have to be Emily’s words over mine. “I told you when we first met, that Emily and I have been best friends since kindergarten,” I said.“I remember that, yes,” he said. I could tell he was getting irritated. I needed to choose my words carefully, to make sure he didn’t feel threatened by me. “We’re not best friends anymore. I’m sure she’s told you that. I hurt her so many times and our friendship ended completely when she moved here. It’s all my fault.”Harry’s face